Mrs. A. T. Goodwin’s Letter to the Provost Marshal, 1866

You ask why I raised my hand to that boy, whyI gave him some raps over the head, you askwhy I took my small riding whip to his shouldershis head, why, you ask, when he would not cut logsat the wood pile. You ask why I took him by the hand &gave him some raps, when not one stick did he cut from twelveto four. I told his mother, my milker washer, I told herin plain words he must do better. I told her all this withoutany improvement. She was insolent, which is why my sonstruck her. He only struck her when she ran from her cabinto pluck up the boy while I was giving him some rapsover the head & shoulders with just my small ridingwhip. Understand, Sir, this boy had not cut more thantwo scant handfuls of wood for my cookstove, but allthe family were engaged to me: his mother, the boyto bring my horses to water, to cut wood, only yesterdayhe said I shall not cut a stick of wood. I shall not touch it. So theseare the negroes we’ve raised, never abused a single one, alwayshad the kindest feelings, the kindest, so long as their conductwere tolerable, so long as I did not have to standby my wood pile, smelling the wood pile, the smell of the sapintolerable from twelve to four, the heave & snap of the clearsap inside the logs, never holding still, so that I had rather standin the house, my hands sifting flour across a board, so thatin truth I had much rather be still, holding nothing butmy riding whip, dark & folded up small.